Testing 3D Printing Filaments at Freezing Temperatures: A Comprehensive Analysis

The recent cold weather in Germany prompted an investigation into how various 3D printing materials perform in freezing temperatures. In this study, common filaments like PLA, ABS, PETG, Nylon, and Polycarbonate were scrutinized for their resilience under extreme cold conditions.

The Baseline: Testing at Ambient Temperatures

Before subjecting the 3D printed samples to freezing temperatures, baseline tests were conducted at around 20°C. This initial evaluation provided a point of reference for the subsequent cold-temperature assessments.

PLA: Showed the highest static strength, breaking at 84kg.
PCMax: Ranked just after PLA, with a breaking point at 82kg.
PETG and Nylon: Failed at approximately 70kg, showcasing noticeable strain before breaking.
ABS: Displayed the lowest strength, failing at 59kg.

Impact Strength Assessment

The impact strength of the materials was evaluated using notched Izod test specimens. Multiple samples were tested for accuracy, with the following observations:

Polycarbonate: Absorbed 71% of the impact energy.
PA-12: Absorbed 36% of the energy.
ABS: Absorbed 30% of the energy.
PETG: Surprisingly displayed better impact strength, absorbing 21% of the energy.
PLA: Showed inferior impact strength, absorbing only 6% of the energy.

Transition to Low Temperatures: The Cold Temperature Performance

To simulate freezing conditions, the samples were cooled down to -20°C using a cooling bath method. While this temperature may not represent the coldest environments, it was sufficient for assessing material performance. Key findings at -20°C:

Polymakers PCMax: Marked a significant decrease in energy absorption compared to ambient tests.
Nylon: Showed a decrease in impact strength from 36% to 25%.
ABS: Sustained its strength relatively well in low temperatures.
PETG: Maintained performance better than anticipated but exhibited a slight decrease in strength.
PLA: Showed minimal change, possibly influenced by test setup resolution.

Surprising Results at Low Temperatures

Contrary to expectations, the samples displayed enhanced load-bearing capacities at -20°C compared to ambient temperatures. The colder environment seemingly increased the materials' strength and reduced ductility, leading to higher failure loads. This shift in behavior highlighted the intricate relationship between ductility and strength in varying temperature conditions.

Real-world Implications and Conclusion

Ductility plays a crucial role in determining a material's resilience, with ductile materials offering superior overload performance. While the study revealed changes in material properties at low temperatures, the 3D printed parts remained functional, albeit with altered characteristics. As temperatures drop further, materials may become increasingly brittle and less usable.

Share Your Experiences

The blog author invites readers to share their experiences with 3D prints in cold environments. Have you encountered part failures in extreme winter conditions? Your insights and anecdotes are welcomed in the comments section.

If you found this analysis informative, consider supporting the author's work by liking the video, sharing it, and subscribing to the channel. For more engaging content and to support ongoing research efforts, explore the additional videos on the CNC Kitchen channel.

Meta description: Exploring the impact of freezing temperatures on popular 3D printing filaments like PLA, ABS, PETG, Nylon, and Polycarbonate. Discover how these materials perform in cold conditions and their implications for real-world applications.

Keywords: 3D printing, filaments, freezing temperatures, material performance, impact strength, ductility, low temperatures, PLA, ABS, PETG, Nylon, Polycarbonate

Meet Tripo

Discover the capabilities of Tripo and unlock a world of possibilities:

Draft Model Generation: Instantly spark inspiration with our fastest models. Perfect for rapid prototyping and conceptualization, this feature lets you explore various designs or perspectives before diving into detailed modeling. Accepts both text and image input.
Refine Draft Models: Elevate the quality of your initial draft models into finely detailed creations. Seamlessly transition from conceptual drafts to high-resolution models, streamlining your creative workflow.
Model Animation: Bring your creations to life with automated animation. Transform static models into dynamic animations, enhancing presentations or digital experiences effortlessly.
Stylization and Conversion: Customize and convert your models with unparalleled ease. From transforming models into lego-like or voxel-based versions to supporting format conversion (USDZ or FBX), Tripo offers unique stylization options, ensuring compatibility across platforms and applications while injecting a creative twist into your projects.